This is quite a controversial topic I've been seeing around the internet lately (even since before Brawl's release). A "great" cast of characters made it to Smash Bros Brawl, but for the avid gamer, it just isn't enough. Who would you guys have chosen to appear in Brawl?

Personally, Krystal from Starfox should have made some sort of appearance. Her skills as a playable character could have matched that of Zero-suit Samus, but oh well.

Also, comically speaking, Popeye's Spinach power is a Smash Ball of its own, and he's a formidable fighter. After all, he eats his spinach!

Golden Sun is an amazing RPG that gave us many awesome characters. My favorite being Issac in particular. I suppose he was at least a support trophy, but I'm not the only one who thought his psynergy powers would have made a great addition to Brawl. I've seen multiple movesets thought up for him by others and each one of them looked amazing.

i think rocket and bo or hooly should have made an appearance

i personally think that lucas and captain olimar arent that good and even a half dead fly would own them

I have to disagree on that. If you face someone good with Olimar, you'll get owned, seriously. I've been to tournaments. I've also found that if you practice Lucas enough, he's even better then Ness.

Lucas can have a GODLY second jump if you do PK Fire right when you hit the button. But hmm... Isaac woulda been a good one. I think Phoenix Wright would be kinda cool too. Other than that... Ephraim or some mage from Fire Emblem series.

i think ness is pretty good. i like pokemon trainer he even looks like me same red hat lol same hair and eye colour

mr game and watch rocks i mastered him. his final smash is awesome